Grab your 5-Minute Pre-Stage Power Up Guide
Watch your stage presence soar! CLICK HERE

How do high-performing presenters train?

Just like world-class athletes!

Grab Go For The Gold: Your 5-Minute Pre-Stage Power Up today.

Skip to the content
Blog

Don’t be a trauma dumper: vulnerability vs oversharing in public speaking

Live your truth. Share your story. And when you’re speaking on stage, you have the responsibility to find the right balance. I want to make a distinction between vulnerability and therapy. I think it is supercaliferoshly THRILLING to share from your heart and speak the truth.

When we talk about crafting your signature talk, we focus on storytelling. The audience needs to be invested in you and your story is the primary tool to do so. However, when you share in front of an audience it’s important that you’ve done the necessary emotional and psychological work and do not require anything from the audience except their witnessing and attention.

 

Why we are vulnerable on stage

Vulnerability comes from the Latin vulnerabilis — meaning ‘capable of being wounded.’ In public speaking, I interpret that not as an invitation to bleed out on stage, but as the courageous act of letting others witness you wrestle with something real.

It’s not about shock value or dumping emotional weight on your audience. That’s oversharing. That’s trauma dumping. True vulnerability in public speaking means revealing a lived experience that shaped you and doing so with enough perspective that your audience feels held, not burdened.

When you share powerfully and personally, you’re not asking the audience to rescue you. You’re showing them how you navigated something hard. You’re letting them see the scar, not the open wound.

 

Work through your trauma before you share it on stage

Therapy is thrilling, and frankly necessary for the vast majority of people. Got a therapist? Need a therapist? You do you boo. We love that for you, get all the help you need. Tell them every single detail of your life and let them help you work through all your stuff.  The stage can be therapeutic, but it’s not therapy.  

It’s imperative you come to the stage to share your story without expecting anything in return from your audience. You need to be mentally and emotionally ready, before you begin telling your story.  If the vulnerability that you’re tapping into for your speaking is about your VALIDATION then it’s about you.  If the vulnerability that you’re tapping into for your speaking is about providing VALUE for your audience then it’s about them.

You don’t need your audience to comfort you, or manage you, or manage the person next to them who is suddenly activated because you unintentionally triggered a traumatic response..  You are in the driver’s seat of the narrative and you’re proceeding responsibly ensuring the safety of yourself and your audience.  

 

Oversharing has become normalized 

Vulnerability can be confused with oversharing and therapy. Too often in our influencer, TikTok, reality TV landscape, individuals love a bit of trauma dumping and airing out manic thoughts, big feelings, and rants as an example of their commitment to being authentic and vulnerable.

It feels disingenuous because the driver of sharing isn’t human connection. It’s presentation. Performance. Ego. We’ve all seen the video of someone sobbing in front of the camera trauma dumping.  I often think…they had to set up that shot. They were in the middle of an emotional moment, grabbed their camera, set up a tripod, ensured there was adequate lighting, pressed record, considered how long they would record themselves for. Edited the content and posted it.  It’s about as REAL as the REAL WORLD.

When we coach people through public speaking, building connection with your audience is one of our top priorities. A huge part of that is bringing out true authenticity. You know what we like to say? Just be a fucking person. And that starts with finding the balance between personal stories and trauma dumping.

A red flag for me is a speaker saying, “I’ve never shared this with anyone before.” I hear that and I’m literally out the door.  

 

Vulnerability isn’t always about your content 

At the 2016 Democratic Convention, there were an array of speakers who shared personal stories. For me, the standout in demonstrating vulnerability was Braden Harrington, the 13 year old who stutters. He invited the entire nation into the process of watching him struggle to speak through his stutter. 

You can imagine the time fellow students picked on him or adults who lost patience, telling him to “spit it out”. You can imagine the times you were present to someone stuttering and remained silent while they were berated or picked on. 

As Braden progressed word by word and sentence by sentence, the national audience cheered him on. I was sitting down. As I witnessed what was happening, I stood up and moved in front of the TV. He literally MOVED ME. He had something to share that was greater than him. He allowed us to peer into his perceived weakness, and what we witnessed instead was courage, strength, and resilience.

We call this fighting for your story.

 

Being on stage is a vulnerable experience, especially when you bring difference 

Being on stage is vulnerable no matter who you are. 

And when you bring difference, be that gender presentation, disability, queerness, second languages, or anything else that classifies you as “different” from the classic straight, cisgender, white, male public speaking line up, you are also fighting against assumptions from your audience. Or perhaps your assumptions of what they think of you. 

Audiences need to hear your perspective. They need to learn more about life experiences outside their own. Your very presence on that stage is a gift. So it’s really important we find the right balance between vulnerability and oversharing. 

 

Audiences want your story, not your emotions

One of the traps of “vulnerability” is the manipulation of your audience. A speaker who is insistent that what they want to do is make the audience cry. Many believe that the way to cause an emotional response in your audience is to be emotional yourself. That could not be further from the truth. 

The audience is less interested in your emotion. What is compelling is not just your story but, more importantly, the message or perspective your story is offering.. It is in the struggle and tension of sharing your story and allowing whatever emotion is present to emerge and your persistence  in sharing your story anyway that an audience feels something

Performative displays of emotion do not trigger empathy. If you are all about your tears, that’s about you. If you are committed to your story, emotions be damned, then the emotional experience becomes about us as an audience. 

Ready to step into the spotlight and slay the stage? We have workshops and courses for everyone from public speaking beginners to folks ready to storm the world stage with their signature talk.

Close credits