Grab your 5-Minute Pre-Stage Power Up Guide
Watch your stage presence soar! CLICK HERE

How do high-performing presenters train?

Just like world-class athletes!

Grab Go For The Gold: Your 5-Minute Pre-Stage Power Up today.

Skip to the content
Blog

From a Culture of Cruelty to a Culture of Championing

Why brilliant people go silent at work, and how leaders can build a culture of championing instead.

“Can you fix her?”

I get some version of the same call almost every month. A leader. Lovely human. Genuinely invested in their people.

I take a breath. I smile. And I say: “I’d love to. But can I meet the room first?”

Long pause.

There’s always a long pause.

I’ve been teaching public speaking since 2005 and coaching since 2007, full-time since 2015. Presidential candidates, UN diplomats, First Ladies of seven nations, Fortune 500 executives, activists, founders, on four continents. And here’s what twenty years of rooms have taught me: most of the time, the confidence problem doesn’t live in the person.

It lives in the room.

Can I meet the room first?

Let’s start with the word. (I’m a sucker for etymology.)

Confidence comes from the Latin con, “with,” and fidere, “to trust.” Confidence means with trust.

And here’s what most public speaking training misses: trust is a contract. And every contract has two sides.

The first side is trust in yourself. That’s the part we, at Fearless Communicators, teach, and teach well. Your breath. Your body. Your mindset. Your preparation. Grounding your feet before you open your mouth. All of it matters, and we coach it joyfully all day long.

The second side is trust in the room.

And that’s the bigger question.

Because if I don’t trust the room, I will never be confident.

I can have the most beautiful presentation deck. I can have practiced and memorized every word for my colleagues. And the moment I stand up, my throat still closes, because some part of me already knows what happens to people who speak up here.

They get criticized. They get docked. They get told “that’s stupid.” They get written up. They get a calendar invite the next morning for a “quick chat.”

So they stop raising their hands.

And we call it a confidence problem.

Everyone’s talking about quiet quitting. I’d offer that the bigger problem is muted brilliance: people who are absolutely brilliant and don’t feel safe enough to open their f***ing mouths.

And every meeting they sit through in silence, the organization loses what they know.

They’re not quiet by nature. Somebody pressed mute. Sometimes the room presses it. More often, the room taught them to press it themselves.

And here’s the good news about a mute button: it also unmutes.

Most speaking training treats the symptom: the shaky voice, the vocal fillers, the eye contact, the hedging, the sentence that trails off. I want to go to the root. And the root is the culture.

The culture of cruelty

We all carry the same picture in our heads.

The ballet teacher at the barre, cigarette in one hand, cane in the other, tapping your thigh and telling you you’re fat. The coach on the sideline screaming that you’re lazy, you’re soft, you’ll never make it. The adult who, when you dared to share your opinion, said: “That’s the stupidest thing I’ve ever heard.”

Maybe you had one of them. Maybe you just grew up on the movies about them. Either way, the picture came with a promise: this is how greatness gets made. Break them down. They’ll thank you later.

(I’m baby Gen X, elder millennial. My generation got that promise in stereo.)

Here’s the truth: cruelty is a way. It is not the only way. It’s the way that has a lot of very accomplished people in a lot of very expensive therapy.

And it doesn’t start at the office. It starts much earlier.

I work with a woman who has spent her career in war zones. War zones. And she will tell you, with a completely straight face, that she would rather be back in one than stand on a stage.

When she was eight years old, one of many kids in a big Roman Catholic family, she saw one of those 1980s TV commercials: an orphanage in Eastern Europe, children sobbing. And she decided: We have room. We have a big house. We need to adopt one of these children.

She didn’t just ask. She built a bassinet. She decorated a corner of the room. She made a full presentation to her parents.

Her parents thought she was out of her mind.

The next day at school, she shared her idea. And a nun looked at her and said:

“Stop being a fool. There’s nothing you can do for those children.”

Shutters down.

An eight-year-old with a bassinet and a plan to help an orphan child on the other side of the world learned that speaking from her heart makes you a fool. And she believed it for decades. The irony? Her life’s work is helping young girls find their voices. She just couldn’t find her own.

That’s the culture of cruelty. It’s not one villain. It’s the home, the school, the church, the team, and then the workplace, each one quietly confirming what the last one taught. And almost no one stops to call it what it is.

Cruel.

And this isn’t only an American story. I’ve seen it in boardrooms, classrooms and convenings around the world. Cruelty wears a different costume in every culture. Its impact is always the same.

A cut that bleeds and can mortally wound.

And at work, here’s the part we don’t say out loud: most people aren’t building confidence. They’re being forced, in big ways and small, to perform their boss’s version of it. Lower your voice. Stop moving your hands. Be more “executive.”

That’s not confidence. That’s an ill-fitting costume.

Feedback feeds. Criticism cuts.

None of this means we stop telling the truth. I’m with Brené Brown: clear is kind. You can hold someone accountable. You can tell them the opening could be stronger and the data slide made everyone check their phones. The question isn’t whether you tell the truth. It’s what the truth is for.

Feedback feeds. Criticism cuts.

Feedback is nourishment. Sometimes it’s bitter, like medicine, but you can taste that it was made to help you grow. Criticism’s job is to make you smaller. And in so many organizations, what gets called “candid feedback” or “brutal honesty” is criticism that bought a nicer suit and learned to show up to the performance review on time.

You feel the difference in your body before your brain catches up. Feedback leaves you steadier, even when it stings. Criticism leaves you scanning for the exit.

The culture of championing

So if not cruelty, then what?

I’ve been searching for the right C-word. (Settle down.)

And I found it in the dictionary, which, as you know, is my happy place.

Champion comes from the Late Latin campio: a fighter in the campus, the field. A champion is someone who steps onto the field on your behalf.

Now look around the arena. There are three roles in it.

The gladiator is there to take you down and leave you bleeding in the sand. The emperor watches from the box and decides your fate with a thumb. And the champion? The champion comes down into the sand.

Too many workplaces are running gladiator games and calling it professional development. We cut people down, leave them bleeding, and then wonder why they don’t come back stronger. (Spoiler: it’s very hard to grow a limb back #tisafleshwound.)

A culture of championing holds people accountable and roots for them at the same time. It’s clear. It’s kind. It’s on your side of the arena. It celebrates your growth instead of waiting for your failure.

Remember the woman who’d rather be in a war zone?

Years later, she’s my client. We’ve crafted her talk together. Rehearsed. Ready. And moments before she’s supposed to walk on stage, she turns to me: “I can’t do it. I can’t do it.”

I look her in the eyes and say: “On the other side of you walking on that stage and opening your mouth is the transformation. You’ve done the work. Walk through the fog of fear. Ground yourself on that stage. Inhale deeply and release the shame. Share from your heart.”

She walks out. She blacks out for part of it. She delivers every word anyway.

And when she comes off that stage, she says: “Oh my God. I’m alive.”

She has since spoken at the UN and on stages around the world.

Nothing about her brilliance changed that night. What changed was the room, and her relationship to it. For decades, she had carried her parents and that nun into every room she walked into. That night, for the first time, she was standing in the proverbial arena where everyone was on her side.

That’s championing.

Why one workshop won’t build a culture of championing

Now I’m going to say something that may sound strange coming from a man who runs workshops and trainings for a living:

One two-hour workshop on presence is a great start. But it will not fix this.

(Please still book the workshop. It’s fun, practical, and profound.)

Ronald Heifetz draws a distinction between technical and adaptive challenges. Speaking is both. You learn the technique: the breath, the structure, the story. Then you have to practice it, out loud, in rooms that reinforce your growth instead of punishing your first try.

Think about the speakers you admire. They have aptitude, yes. They also have reps. You’ve heard of Malcolm Gladwell’s 10,000 hours. I have my quibbles with the number, but not with the point: you get better by practicing. Not by thinking about it. Not by avoiding it. Not by resisting it. By getting out into the arena. Nobody wakes up at 35, having never spoken up anywhere, and knocks it out of the park when everything is on the line.

So a culture of championing is also a culture of practice. An arena where we get better together. Where it’s safe to be a work in progress. And while you’re training, it’s best to have a champion in the arena with you.

Out in the world, there will be lions. You can’t control that. But the practice field is where we get people ready to face them. It’s not where we wound them before they ever reach the arena.

The Trust Contract

So let’s name it. I call it the Trust Contract.

Contract comes from the Latin con and trahere, “to draw together.” A contract is never one-sided. It takes two signatures. And confidence, with trust, has two signatories: you and the room.

Your side: Competence. Competence comes from com and petere, “to strive together,” to be fit for the moment. It’s the practice of building the skill: developing the technique, rep by rep, until you trust yourself in the moments that matter, when everything is on the line. Your body, your voice, your story, your preparation. This is the side almost every speaking training teaches.

The room’s side: Culture. Culture comes from colere, “to tend, to cultivate,” the way you’d tend a field. The room’s job is to cultivate a practice ground where competence can grow: a culture of championing, not a culture of cruelty. This is the side almost nobody teaches.

Including, for most of my career, me. Here’s how I see the work now. Phase one is the individual: building the competence to be confident. We’ve done it for twenty years, and we’re not stopping. It’s affirming, powerful work. But I’ve watched brilliant people walk out of a great session and straight back into a room that mutes them. So phase two is the room: the culture, and whether it helps confidence thrive. It’s the phase many organizations resist, or don’t know exists. And it’s what makes phase one stick. One without the other doesn’t hold. Together, that’s where the transformation lives.

And that transformation is everything. It’s the health of your culture. It’s whether your best people stay. And it’s every amazing idea you haven’t even considered yet, because it’s sitting in your next meeting right now. In silence. Muted.

Confidence happens when both sides keep their end of the deal. That’s when people unmute.

Muted brilliance has two buttons. You can press one. The room can press the other. Unmuting takes both.

And here’s the breach I see over and over: organizations hold their people to their side of the contract and rarely, if ever, keep their own.

Look at the words again. Confidence. Contract. Competence. Every one of them begins with with.

None of this happens alone.

So: build a culture of championing

Three things to try this week:

  1. Ask the champion question. Before you give any feedback: am I helping this person build something, or proving I’m the smartest one at the table?
  2. Build a practice field. Give people low-stakes reps before high-stakes moments: a dry run with allies before the board presentation, not “you’re presenting in ten minutes.”
  3. Name growth out loud. Start with what the speaker did well, by name, in front of the team, and train the room to look for it. Then let the speaker name the one area where they want support, and focus the feedback there. Let everyone learn that growth gets noticed here, not just mistakes.

And to every manager, teacher, coach and parent who has ever stepped into the arena for someone else, who said “keep going” when they could have said “stop being a fool”: thank you. You are the reason someone, somewhere, is speaking today.

The nun didn’t set out to silence a child for decades. She said the easy thing in a room she had the power to shape.

You have that power in every room you walk into.

So who will you be in that arena: the emperor, or the champion?

Who championed you? Who stepped into the arena on your behalf when you were ready to bail? Reply and tell me. I want to know.

Fearlessly yours,

Eduardo

Close credits